Why I’m Still Holding On To My Old MacBook Pro

The outer case is scratched and dented, the original 160GB hard drive has been replaced with a 250Gb model that is now close to full, I’m on my third battery, the number of times that I have to do a hard shutdown is occurring more and more frequently, and the heat that comes from the underside has probably scarred my legs for life. So why do I continue using it instead of upgrading to a new model? Well, there are more than a few reasons that I just don’t want to bite the bullet just quite yet.

Let’s start with the easy one first, price. Apple products are anything but cheap and the MacBook Pro is no exception. The bottom of the line 15″ model will run you about $1800 US. Of course I am not one to go with the bottom of the line so I would be looking at the Core i7 version so that jacks the price tag up to the $2200 level.   Yes, I do understand that you get what you pay for and Mac products are typically rock solid but still, that’s a lot of coin to dig out of the couch cushions.

The next consideration is the battery. As I said above, I am on my third battery and probably need to be thinking about buying my fourth. I can only get about 30 minutes out of my current battery before I am down to one sad little blinking led indicator. And this leads me to my trepidation about buying a computer whose battery is built into the system. I do understand that Apple has packed a lot of power cells into the body and claims somewhere in the neighborhood of 8-9 hours of battery life but the reality is that batteries lose charge over time and at some point it will need to be replaced. And unlike my current Mac, a replacement will require a trip to the Genius Bar and, what I am guessing would be a pretty decent chunk of cash to have the Apple experts crack the unibody and load in a replacement. My current MacBook Pro battery will cost about $129 + tax so I can’t imagine what one on the new Mac will cost when you add in labor charges.

This last one isn’t really a deal breaker but it is something that I have given a lot of thought to; that beautiful, but way to glossy screen. It really is something to behold but it can also be very annoying to have all that glare in your face when you spend a lot of time working on your computer. I love my non-glare screen on my MBP and don’t want to give it up. Of course Apple knows this so they offer the option of a high-res antiglare display for an additional $150. Okay, $150 doesn’t seem like that much but when you add it to the $2200 price tag it’s just one more expense that really makes me have to think about the upgrade.

So what are my options? Well, I could go a little cheaper and consider a Windows-based laptop. I already have an i7 desktop that I love but I just can’t imagine not having a Mac in my life, especially for my portable computing. I could bite the bullet and pry open the wallet. Or, I can consider a third option, rebuild my trusty MBP and squeeze another year or two out of it. This last option is really the one that I am currently considering the most. Another battery will cost me $129 but I think replacing my current hard drive with an SSD would give me a performance boost that would really take things up a notch or two. Of course a 360GB SSD runs about $1000 so I would still be in for about half the cost of a new model.

So is it really worth it to not just go the rest of the way? I’m not sure but for now, maybe I’ll just grab me some duct tape and think on it for a little bit longer. If you have taken the plunge, I would love to hear about your experience and whether or not you think it was worth the price of  upgrading.

  • Pingback: Booom

  • Pingback: Alltop Photography

  • Pingback: Craig Judd

  • http://www.chromasia.com/iblog/ David J. Nightingale

    I recently had much the same dilemma but decided to upgrade to the new 2.66GHz Core i7 15″ Macbook Pro. I couldn’t afford a decent sized SSD, so went with the 500GB conventional drive instead. However, I did go for 8GB of RAM which has made a huge difference for me, mostly because I can now reap the benefits of running Photoshop in 64 bit mode – it’s massively faster with more memory. So, I feel your pain – it’s an expensive upgrade – but I do think it’s worth the money. As for the battery, I guess I’ll cross that bridge when I get to it, but I’m not looking forward to the additional expense.

  • http://methodphoto.com Richard Earney

    Actually cracking open a new MacBook Pro is dead simple, and it goes back together nicely too, unlike older models. Once your warranty is over then replacing the battery is pretty simple too, http://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Repair/Installing-MacBook-Pro-15-Inch-Unibody-Mid-2010-Battery/3024/1

    You can fit more RAM in too (up to 8GB). Yes it is an investment and a more durable one!

  • Bill

    Check Apple’s refurb section for MBP’s. As of this morning (10/25/10 0855) 4 core i7′s are listed ranging in price from $1869 to $2549 (w/SSD). There is a MBP Core i7 2.66GHZ 4GB RAM 500 GB HD non-glossy screen for $1999. Occasionally with a refurbished Mac, I’ve received a ‘silent upgrade’ … i.e. more RAM or larger HD.

  • Pingback: Brad Gerrard

  • skooker reid

    What I do: identify the model I like, wait for Apple to issue its replacement, then swoop in and buy a refurbished unit of the old model at Apple.

  • http://williambeem.com William Beem

    You don’t have to imagine how much it will cost to replace your battery. Apple posts the prices here: http://www.apple.com/support/macbookpro/service/battery/

  • Steve Kalman

    My Desktop philosophy: Buy with room to upgrade, and buy upgradeable parts (e.g., my motherboard maxed out at 8GB RAM, I started with 4, and will upgrade soon)

    My Laptop philosophy: Buy the best I can find/afford, then keep it until I can’t stand it any more. The only thing I’ve ever upgraded on a laptop is to get a larger hard drive.

    If Mac had a tablet PC, I’d buy it today. I’m currently using a Fujitsu tablet with Win 7/64. The tablet screen/interface is built by Wacom and is pressure sensitive in PS/LR. I do preliminary edits while traveling (saving all layers, etc.) and then finish it at home.

  • Arthur Agin

    Jeff,

    Two comments.

    Samsung makes a hybrid drive that combines a HD with SSD. I think it’s the Momentus XT and is available up to 500GB. I think they’re only $50 more and performs in between HD and SSD.

    I would also wait until Apple catches up on screen resolution. The best they offer is a 1600×1050 while the high end standard is now 1920×1080.

    Art

    • Jared Chapin

      Morning Jeff. 2007 Macbook Pro here. Express Card 34. I use it so that I have eSATA. I like the what they got. I just Find it missing. USB 3.0—eSATA—what about FW 1600 or 3200. I really want the express card back in the 15”…getting greedy here a 1gig graphics card. & cheeper SSD drives.